logo

Bangalee Muslim or Muslim Bangalee? : The Rise of Political Islam and the Crisis of Personal Freedom in Bangladesh

Dr. Mahmud M. Hasan
Bangalee Muslim or Muslim Bangalee?
: The Rise of Political Islam and the Crisis of Personal Freedom in Bangladesh
AI generated image

For years, I have been writing on social media about how religion, the rituals, the symbols, the emotional charge of it, is used in Bangladesh as a tool of social control rather than as a guide to spirituality. Religion, particularly Islam, is deeply intertwined with politics, group identity and

public morality, so there is little space for individual belief. In Bangladesh, as the government

Advertisement

seeks political legitimacy through religion, ordinary citizens increasingly feel pressured to

conform.

My discomfort with religious interference was initiated early in my life. I was raised in a traditional rural Muslim family and was encouraged to practice Islam but never compelled to do so. However, when someone outside the family questioned my religious practice, I felt uncomfortable. I believed that my faith was entirely my own concern.

This discomposure deepened during my time at university. Members of the Tabligh Jamaat regularly visited our student residence, inviting us to attend prayers, religious discussions at the

mosque, and Tablighi tours. The request was not problematic, but their actions presumed that attendance was mandatory as a Muslim. Out of social pressure, on one occasion, I participated in a three-day Tabligh tour. I felt forced; I felt embarrassed. That was a lesson I have never

forgotten: forced faith is not a real faith, and you should not invade someone’s religious functionality.

Two ways of being Muslim in Bangladesh

My personal experience illustrates a broader social phenomenon. Over time, Bangladeshis have

gradually shifted from identifying as Bangalee Muslims, whose cultural identity is rooted in

undivided Bengal, to Muslim Bangalees, who prioritize religious identity over ethnic and cultural heritage. This transformation has significant consequences.

A Bangalee Muslim considers religion a private affair and culture a shared experience. A

Muslim Bangalee, on the other hand, perceives religion as a tool to shape society and will

routinely reject Bangalee culture as un-Islamic. This conflict is largely present in our politics, our society, and our everyday lives.

Although the distinction may seem like mere punning or wordplay, it has a deep impact. It concerns what individuals believe they can impose their beliefs on others. A Bangalee Muslim

can quite happily share language, literature, songs and festivals with neighbours of any faith, as these are cultural things which do not require religious approval. Conversely, a Muslim Bangalee often questions whether sharing culture is permissible and frequently concludes that it is not.

An Islam that grew by accommodation

Historical evidence demonstrates that Islam in this region spread primarily through acceptance

rather than coercion. Between the 8th and 13th centuries, Arab traders and Sufi saints introduced

Islam through kindness, social service, and spiritual appeal. Bengal embraced an eclectic form of Islam that incorporated local customs and norms. Even a few decades ago, Muslims attended Hindu fairs, sang Baul songs, and participated in folk traditions.

The legacy of Bangalee Muslim was reaffirmed in 1971. Bangladesh was not created as a state for a single faith. Its founding promise, articulated in the 1972 constitution, was that Bangalee nationhood, democracy, socialism, and equal citizenship would unite people of diverse religions.

Defending Bangalee culture is not merely nostalgic; it is a defence of the foundational agreement upon which the country was built. Today, this inclusive culture is diminishing due to the rise of organized religious politics or political Islam in Bangladesh.

When preaching becomes a business

The rise of the modern preacher has hastened this process. So many of the Islamic speakers you see on television, on social media, at waz mahfils (sermons) disseminate distorted history, misogyny and hate toward other religions. Their talking-toes are full of fabricated stories,

inappropriate content and incitement to attack non-Muslims and other Muslim groups. They get

away with it completely. In fact, they often become more popular because religious sensationalism gets the public's attention.

Much of this popular religious activity has become commercialized. Sermons of religious speakers generate revenue, audiences are manipulated, and religion is being treated as a commodity. When religious preaching becomes an industry, spiritual values become

subordinated to the pursuit of profit. Consequently, many young men develop a distorted

understanding of religion and receiving little genuine spiritual or moral guidance.

At the same time, political actors have realized that religion is an effective instrument for mobilization, which they have used in modern politics. From the anti-Ahmadiya movement to attacks on Hindu and Buddhist temples, and from branding critics as anti-Islamic (kafir) or

Islamophobic to banning cultural programmes, religion has now become a convenient tool for asserting dominance. The state or the government often ignores these actions or, in some cases, collaborates, as religion delivers political advantages. This failure to maintain the separation

between religion and state is the cause of the impunity and the social unrest that we see.

A state cannot have a religion

The principle remains straightforward: a state cannot possess a religion. A state is a legal entity, not an individual. It cannot pray, fast, or attend a mosque. However, it must protect the rights of all citizens equally, including Muslims, Hindus, Christians, Buddhists, and atheists, as is guaranteed in the constitution as a fundamental right. When the state chooses or favours a

religion, it ends up discriminating against others.

Bangladesh’s founding promise was secularism, defined not as the absence of religion but as the state’s neutrality toward all religions. That promise has diminished. Contemporary social unrest, religious intolerance, and frequent communal conflicts indicate this decline. I argue that if

religion continues to be intertwined with politics, both religion and the nation will be weakened.

I say this because I was brought up in the principle of equity and compassion. I support secularism and the 1972 constitution, not as a rejection of religion. I have seen what happens when religion is forced upon people. Any faith that relies on the police, the mob, or the state to survive has already surrendered its claim to true spirituality.

The way forward is personal freedom

A viable path forward begins with restoring personal freedom. Religion should be confined to private life. Individuals should be free to pray, fast, perform puja, or attend prayer halls

according to their own choice. Parents may convey religious values to their children, but they should also instill tolerance. Until their children reach maturity, parents should shield them from external religious pressures. Once they become adults, they must have the autonomy to choose their own spiritual path. Islam itself communicates that ‘there is no compulsion in religion'. Coercion affects personal dignity and violates the faith it purports to defend.

Bangladesh stands at a crossroads. The nation should not continue intertwining religion with

politics, which leads to division, hypocrisy, and intolerance; instead, it can reclaim its tradition of

pluralism and cultural richness. Maintaining a separation between religion and politics will not

undermine faith; rather, it will strengthen society.

It is now the time to ask:

Will we be Bangalee Muslims who are proud of our culture and our individuality, or will we be Muslim Bangalees whose very identity is defined by fear, by coercion and by political control?

Our future hinges on the answer.

The opinions expressed in this article are the author’s own. It does not necessarily reflects Asia Post’s editorial policy.

_______________________________________

About the author: Dr Mahmud M Hasan is an Associate Professor of Law at Carleton University, Ottawa, Canada